First steps towards a tipping point in reinsurance?

This past Thursday, an interesting bill was passed by the Florida legislature. Described by Insurance Information Institute President Robert Hartwig as having "effectively socialized the insurance and reinsurance markets in the state", the bill is one that potentially could have negative consequences for Bermuda’s reinsurance markets both in the near term and future.

News reports have describing it as an increase in the financial contribution to the state’s Hurricane Catastrophe Fund, which would cause the state itself to take on the insurance risk of a catastrophe. What will this mean for our reinsurance industry and what kind of impacts could it have on Bermuda’s economy? Is it possible it could create a trend?

Is Florida making a huge gamble by taking on it’s own risks of disaster? If this coming summer becomes anything like the last, then the gamble could pay off, at least in the short term. If this coming summer is more like 2004, then the gamble could come at quite a loss. If the gamble doesn’t go in their favor, it would be likely to see taxes rise to extraordinary levels to cover the costs.

What impact could this gamble have on Bermuda’s insurance industry? Well, if this summer turns out to be a mild one, how likely is it that other states or even countries, may decide to make a similar move? Could such decisions create a trend that potentially could eliminate much of the profit found in reinsurance, effectively toppling Bermuda’s prime industry.

Certainly this writer is no expert on reinsurance, however some questions do need to be asked. It may be unlikely for this one legal change to cause a trend, however, can we be certain that there won’t ever be similar changes worldwide that could effectively wipe out Bermuda’s economy in an instant? Perhaps this is something we should ever be wary of.

At least for now, you are left to your own devices to determine the odds for the future of Bermuda’s reinsurance industry. One thing is certain, however. This writer won’t be buying property in Florida anytime soon.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized by . Bookmark the permalink.

4 thoughts on “First steps towards a tipping point in reinsurance?

  1. Hey Denis,
    I wouldn’t call this a tipping point and I wouldn’t call it a socialist solution to the problem. I don’t really want to post my reasons why on this (or any) site, and I don’t have your e-mail, but send me an e-mail and we can get together and I’ll try and convince you that the impact of the programme is not all it is stated to be.

  2. Thanks for the comment tilti. I likely should have worded the title differently. My intention was to portray it as one step that may lead towards a tipping point, not as a tipping point itself.

  3. “effectively socialized the insurance and reinsurance markets in the state”
    I wouldn’t even say that this is correct. Socialism is a sharing of wealth and/or services to the poor. This may be the complete opposite as at the ultimate extreme poor people in rural America will be called upon to bail out the FHCF (because it has no money) effectively subsidizing the insurance costs of the rich owners of expensive coastal property. Nothing socialist about it, it is potentially an ugly regressiev tax on the poor.

  4. Hmm. I can’t speak for the individual himself but According to the American Heritage Dictionary, socialize is defined as “To place under government or group ownership or control.”
    By this definition, insurance in the state has been placed under government control as it effectively puts government ownership on the risk of catastrophe.
    So, in principle is this not socialist?
    Unfortunately, due to the disproportionate spread of rich vs poor, I tend to agree with your assessment that if a catastrophe does occur, the majority (who likely are unwealthy) will have to suffer the brunt of covering the losses of the rich minority.
    Your expectations appear to meet more of a communist definition of abolishing private ownership. (making all citizens equitibly balanced)

Comments are closed.